We measured my 10 year old to be sure the fit was correct, as she grows daily and I wasn't sure what size she was at this moment. The shoe arrived about a week after we ordered them, fit like a glove and looked great. She wore them to five musical rehearsals and the elastic broke on the buckle....not something you can return when the shoes have been worn for about 15 hours. I marked "fair", which is a shame because they are attractive, took about a week to arrive, and fit perfectly based on their size chart. I can't mark excellent due to the shoe coming apart so quickly after purchasing. I used a needle and thread to sew the elastic together so that she could keep wearing the shoes, but have no idea how long that will last. Probably as long as her foot is a size 7.5, which is lucky for us...if you are an adult I'd be cautious about ordering this shoe, as you'd want them for quite a bit longer than that!